PP-R-DNN-10195228Not received$27.00
Marisol Reyes, store order HC-212721
We will refund the $27.00 charge in full because we cannot prove delivery.
Our notes show the order shipped First-Class without tracking.
Quote matched in Exhibit H: “Shipped First-Class without tracking”, word for word.
The buyer reported that the vase had not arrived and asked for a refund if it was lost.
Quote matched in Exhibit D: “I'd like a refund if it's lost.”, word for word.
We did not answer the buyer's two emails before the chargeback.
For the seller
- The checkout policy disclosed that orders under $40 ship without tracking unless the buyer adds it.F
For the buyer
- The shipment was sent without tracking, so no carrier delivery record exists.H
- The buyer reported that the vase had still not arrived and later requested a refund if lost.D
- The requirements card has no carrier number, delivered scan, address confirmation, or signature.B, H
Refund itEvidence balance 10% for the seller
$27.00 at stake
Refund in full because shipment has no tracking or delivery proof.
Argued by GPT-5.6 on Azure OpenAI in 7.7 s. Every figure and name checked against the exhibit it cites.