Exhibit
DeskPayPal reviewing

“Charged twice”, already refunded

Slate mug, $46. The buyer double-clicked checkout; the second charge was refunded the next day.

PP-R-DQR-10190307Charged twice$46.00

Hannah Weiss, store order HC-80987

The checkout page froze and processed two charges for store order HC-80987.

We refunded the duplicate charge in full for $46.00.

Refund 6ED91706RN309632X has status Completed.

The refund note identifies it as the duplicate charge for the same order.

We ask that the chargeback be denied because the duplicate charge has already been refunded.

For the seller
  • Refund 6ED91706RN309632X shows the duplicate $46.00 charge was refunded with status Completed.D
  • The buyer reported two charges, and we confirmed that two charges went through and told the buyer the second was refunded.G
  • The seller's notes confirm the checkout froze, took payment twice, and the second $46.00 charge was refunded in full.K
For the buyer
  • The cardholder says they were charged twice for one purchase.A

Fight it88% chance for the seller

$46.00 at stake

The duplicate $46.00 charge was already refunded in full; submit the completed refund record.

Argued by GPT-5.6 on Azure OpenAI in 4.8 s. Every sentence checked against its exhibits.

Filed

  1. 4 Oct 2026, 23:23Filed the response (5 sentences) and 11 exhibits as proof of refund.

PayPal now shows this case as PayPal reviewing, with the seller's evidence on file. On a card chargeback the issuing bank makes the final call; this page updates when PayPal does.

In the sandbox nobody at PayPal reads the evidence. When PayPal opens the case for a ruling (about 20 minutes after filing), you can ask its simulator to decide. It rules the way the filing points.