PP-R-HWG-10195220Not as described$136.00
Marcus Bell, store order HC-160673
The buyer did not return the bowls because of the expected return-shipping cost.
Quote matched in Exhibit F: “Return shipping for three bowls would be about $30.”, word for word.
We offered a return within 30 days for a refund.
Our listing disclosed that the tide-blue glaze can shift from deep blue to green where it pools.
Quote matched in Exhibit G: “colour shifts from deep blue to green where the glaze pools”, word for word.
Our checkout policy states that the buyer pays return shipping unless the piece arrived damaged.
Quote matched in Exhibit H: “The buyer pays return shipping unless the piece arrived damaged.”, word for word.
For the seller
- The buyer did not return the bowls, citing that return shipping “would be about $30.”F
- We offered a return within 30 days for a refund before the chargeback opened.F, A
- The listing disclosed that the tide-blue glaze shifts from deep blue to green where it pools.G
- The checkout policy states that buyers pay return shipping unless a piece arrived damaged.H
For the buyer
- The buyer reported that the bowls were much greener than the photos and did not match his blue dishes.F
Fight itOutcome: won, the seller keeps the $136.00; $116.00 after PayPal's $20.00 fee, charged either way
Fight: the buyer did not return the bowls after we offered a refund return, and the listing disclosed green colour shifts.
Argued by GPT-5.6 on Azure OpenAI in 8.5 s. Every figure and name checked against the exhibit it cites.