PP-R-IPX-10195230Unauthorised$180.00
Zoe Fischer, store order HC-214525
USPS delivered the order signed by Z FISCHER in Madison, WI 53703.
The same customer had two earlier orders that were delivered to the same address and never disputed.
This order used the same device and IP address as those earlier orders.
Quote matched in Exhibit L: “This order's device: AGT-7F3A-90C2”, word for word.
The cardholder's signed instruction to the shopping agent allowed dinner plates under $200.00 delivered to the order address.
Withdrawn at the hearing before filing, after objection 4: What evidence ties wallet key wallet-07ae79c97d03 to Zoe Fischer beyond the agent platform's own assertion?
The mandate check verified both signatures, confirmed the cart matched the intent and PayPal order, and assigned responsibility to the cardholder.
Withdrawn at the hearing before filing, after objection 3: Where is the 3-D Secure authentication result or liability shift for this Mastercard transaction?
We ask that the $180.00 chargeback be denied based on this evidence of cardholder participation.
For the seller
- USPS recorded delivery signed by Z FISCHER in Madison, WI 53703 before the case opened.I, A
- Two earlier orders were never disputed and used the same device, IP address, and delivery address.L
- The cardholder's signed instruction allowed dinner plates under $200.00 delivered to the order address.D
- The verified cart matched the signed intent, and the mandate check assigned responsibility to the cardholder.F
- Street, ZIP, and security code matched, although these checks alone do not establish cardholder participation.C
For the buyer
- No 3-D Secure result or liability shift is on file.A
Fight itEvidence balance 85% for the seller
$180.00 at stake
Fight: signed delivery, matching prior orders, and the agent mandate support cardholder participation.
Argued by GPT-5.6 on Azure OpenAI in 9.3 s. Every figure and name checked against the exhibit it cites.