PP-R-YAC-10195241Not received$104.00
Sofia Marchetti, store order HC-294182
USPS shows the parcel was delivered and signed for on 22 Oct 2026 in Palo Alto, CA 94301 by S MARCHETTI at the front desk.
Our order required shipment to Sofia Marchetti at 845 Alma Street, Unit 12, Palo Alto, CA 94301.
The chargeback opened on 29 Oct 2026, after the recorded delivery.
PayPal has USPS tracking number 9405511206213810067741 on file for payment 4RP86153KY1723410.
We ask that the chargeback be denied based on the carrier’s signed proof of delivery.
Quote matched in Exhibit I: “Latest: Delivered, signed”, word for word.
For the seller
- USPS recorded delivery on 22 Oct 2026 at 13:00 in Palo Alto, CA 94301, signed by S MARCHETTI at the front desk.I
- The transaction instructed shipment to Sofia Marchetti at 845 Alma Street, Unit 12, Palo Alto, CA 94301.B
- Delivery occurred before the case opened on 29 Oct 2026.I, A
- PayPal has USPS tracking number 9405511206213810067741 on file for payment 4RP86153KY1723410.H
For the buyer
- The cardholder says the merchandise was not received.A
Fight itOutcome: won, the seller keeps the $104.00; $84.00 after PayPal's $20.00 fee, charged either way
Fight: USPS shows signed delivery to the buyer’s ZIP before the chargeback opened.
Argued by GPT-5.6 on Azure OpenAI in 9.7 s. Every figure and name checked against the exhibit it cites.